LB - Coldwell Banker 1019

Home | Classifieds | Place Ad | Public Notices | Galleries | Kudos | Obits | Real Estate | Subscriber Services | Villager | Health Directory | Contact Us
The Verde Independent | Cottonwood, Arizona

home : sports : local May 24, 2016

2/21/2012 11:44:00 AM
COMMENTARY: AIA power-point system brought into question
MacKenzie Mabery heads the ball in an attempt to score with less than a minute left in the second-round Division III playoff game against Seton Catholic Saturday, Feb. 4 in Chandler. Mabery’s header bounced off the crossbar. VVN/Sean Morris
MacKenzie Mabery heads the ball in an attempt to score with less than a minute left in the second-round Division III playoff game against Seton Catholic Saturday, Feb. 4 in Chandler. Mabery’s header bounced off the crossbar. VVN/Sean Morris

Sean Morris
Sports Reporter

If you have an interest in Arizona high school sports, you probably heard about the concern over the shaky power-point system this year.

Power points determine which teams make the playoffs and what seed they deserve. It's never been a perfect system, but the formula implemented last school year was supposed be better. It isn't.

The mathematical reason is convoluted and hard to understand; the crux of the issue lies in the current formula rewarding teams that play more power-point games.

Hard evidence of this issue popped up when basketball teams tried to find out if they were playoff bound before the sectional tournaments. They found out teams that simply made their sectional tournament and lost received a bump in the standings over teams that didn't make their sectional.

This phenomenon highlighted an existing issue; teams with fewer games scheduled in the regular season were getting the short end of the stick. In general, it also means rural teams are disadvantaged because most of the time they play fewer games.

Look no further than Mingus girls' soccer. They had a tremendous team this year with great defense and arguably the best scorer in the state, Torey Braly. Their only loss during the regular season was in a shootout to the Eagles in Flagstaff, a Division II powerhouse that went undefeated in the regular season. Mingus' earned an 11-1 regular season record.

With the faulty system, the Marauders earned a 5 seed in the Division III playoffs. Weirdly, the AIA gave two home games to the top four seeds, so that meant (5) Mingus played (4) Seton Catholic at Seton Catholic in the second round. The Sentinels earned a 12-1 record with their only loss coming to Division II Queen Creek.

Mingus was missing one of their best players, Braly wasn't 100 percent, and Seton won the game against Mingus, 1-0. It was a great game, Seton played inspired, and I wouldn't want to take anything away from them, but the game should not have been played on Seton's field.

Right off the bat, giving the top four seeds two home playoff games was a poor choice. It was intended to cut down on cost, but some have called that into question. I don't know if it saved money or not, but it was still unfair.

Even if the power-point formula was impenetrable and the seeding was absolutely correct, the difference between the 5 and 4 seeds is so minute, it doesn't make sense to reward a 4 seed with two home games and give the 5 none.

Secondly, since Seton Catholic played one more game than Mingus, their power points were given more weight. Since Seton is based in Chandler, they're closer to a boatload more schools than Mingus. It's easier for them to schedule games. It's also easier for their opponents to schedule games, and since opponents' victory points are woven into the current system, it unintentionally rewards metropolitan teams that play each other.

It's important to remember the AIA does a lot of things right, but they obviously need to fix this issue. Some teams potentially deserved playoff berths and were snubbed. Other teams were given the wrong seed, and it goes across all sports.

Hopefully this gets fixed before baseball and softball season, but if you're waiting for the AIA to admit fault, don't hold your breath. For this to change, schools need to unite and make this issue a priority.

To see the math behind the flaw, check John Carrieres' work by following this link. He's been the main whistle blower campaigning for a change.

Carrieres crunched the numbers, and in an email he wrote "Mingus would have been a top 4 seed if the formula was correct.  Seton would not have been. My niece played for Seton. My wife teaches there.  I told my niece at the time that they should not have been a 4 seed. Mingus could have ended as high as 3 but probably 4."

This example shows Carrieres is only interested in fairness, and the AIA should be too.

ICT - Lamb Auto 0501 Nissan 180x150

    Most Viewed     Recently Commented
•   Police soon will have one more reason to pull you over (4332 views)

•   'A Great Celebration' -- Mingus seniors prepare for graduation, commemorate scholarships and awards (3523 views)

•   What's hot in Verde Valley job market? (2684 views)

•   Cornville man charged with child molestation seeks plea (2503 views)

•   Still no final answer on Prop. 123 (2246 views)

Reader Comments

Posted: Thursday, February 23, 2012
Article comment by: very apt for us up north

since its not so easy for us to pick up extra 'fluff' games like those in the more metro areas... unless we travel a long distance... which is what the AIA used as an excuse for the revamp...

keep up the good work mr. morris... 8^)

Posted: Thursday, February 23, 2012
Article comment by: Albert Rodriguez

Good Work Sean!

Article Comment Submission Form
Comments are not posted immediately. Submissions must adhere to our Use of Service Terms of Use agreement. Rambling or nonsensical comments may not be posted. Comments are limited to Facebook character limits. In order for us to reasonably manage this feature we may limit excessive comment entries.
Submit an Article Comment
First Name:
Last Name:
Anti-SPAM Passcode Click here to see a new mix of characters.
This is an anti-SPAM device. It is not case sensitive.

Advanced Search

HSE - Sports Facebook Button
HSE - We want to hear from you
HSE - Father Son Look a Like Contest
Find more about Weather in Cottonwood, AZ
Click for weather forecast

Submission Links
 •  Submit your feedback about our site

Find It Features Blogs Celebrate Submit Extras Other Publications Local Listings
Classifieds | Place Ad | Galleries | Kudos | Real Estate | Subscriber Services | e-News | RSS | Site Map | Find Verde Jobs | Contact Us
LB - Yavapai Herbal Services

© Copyright 2016 Western News&Info, Inc.® The Verde Independent is the information source for Cottonwood and Verde Valley area communities in Northern Arizona. Original content may not be reprinted or distributed without the written permission of Western News&Info, Inc.® Verde News Online is a service of WNI. By using the Site, ®, you agree to abide and be bound by the Site's terms of use and Privacy Policy, which prohibit commercial use of any information on the Site. Click here to submit your questions, comments or suggestions. Verde News Online is a proud publication of Western News&Info Inc.® All Rights Reserved.

Software © 1998-2016 1up! Software, All Rights Reserved