Coldwell Banker

Home | Classifieds | Place Ad | Public Notices | Galleries | Kudos | Obits | Real Estate | Subscriber Services | Villager | Amazing Grapes | Yellow Pages | Contact Us
The Verde Independent | Cottonwood, Arizona

home : latest news : latest news August 20, 2014

10/27/2009 1:32:00 PM
U.S. Supreme Court to decide challenge to tax credits for private schools

Howard Fischer
Capitol Media Services

PHOENIX -- The future of a challenge to Arizona's controversial tax credits to help students go to private and parochial schools will have to be decided by the U.S. Supreme Court.

In a split decision, the majority of the full 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals refused to disturb a ruling of a three-judge panel that foes of state tuition tax credits for private and parochial schools are entitled to try to prove they are unconstitutional.

Tim Keller, attorney for the Institute for Justice which is defending the credits, vowed to take the issue to the Supreme Court. He said the appellate court got it wrong in concluding that the credits, at least the way they work in Arizona, amount to the state advancing the cause of religion.

The decision, by itself, does not void the credits. But unless overturned, it gives challengers the first real chance they have to make their case that the program effectively has the government illegally aiding in religious instruction.

The law allows individuals to donate up to $500 -- $1,000 for married couples -- to organizations that provide scholarships for students to attend private and parochial schools. There is no actual cost to the donors as they can deduct the amount contributed on a dollar-for-dollar basis from their state income tax liability.

In 2008, the most recent year for which numbers are available, Arizona resident diverted nearly $55.3 million to these tuition organizations that otherwise would go to the state treasury.

Foes filed suit, saying the plan is unconstitutional because the law has the effect of giving most of the money to religious schools.

In 2005, U.S. District Court Judge Earl Carroll said that may be true. But Keller argued -- and Carroll agreed -- that as long as donors are free to decide without state interference where to give money, and parents decide where to send their children to school, there is no constitutional violation.

In Wednesday's decision, though, Judge Dorothy Nelson said the evidence shows that isn't the way the program actually works in Arizona.

She said children who want scholarships from certain organizations are restricted to using them to attend specific religious schools. That, the judge said, is different than an Ohio program whose legality was upheld by the U.S. Supreme Court where a parent is given a tuition voucher he or she is free to use at any secular or religious school.

And there is far more money available for religious school scholarships than for help in going to secular schools, she said, money that came from that dollar-for-dollar state tax credit.

Keller acknowledged that is true. But he said that is only because taxpayers, who are free to give -- or not -- to any tuition organization chose to give more money to certain ones than others. That simply means they have more money to give out to students willing to attend the schools they support.

More to the point, Keller said nothing in the law itself creates that situation.

"It has to be state action that results in any sort of any advancement of religion' to run afoul of U.S. Supreme Court precedent, he said. "Here, the program is entirely governed by private action.'

Keller said that the situation would have been entirely different if Arizonans had chosen to give more money to organizations that help students attend secular schools. But in either event, he said, state government did not create the situation.

The two largest recipients of tax credit donations are the Catholic Tuition Organization of the Phoenix Diocese and the Arizona Christian School Tuition Organization restricts its scholarships to be used at "evangelical' Christian schools.

    Recently Commented     Most Viewed
Letters: Who is right is best satisfied by what is right (2 comments)
County votes 'No' on wolves (1 comment)
Cottonwood Elementary works to rectify AIMS stumble (8 comments)
AIMS scores mostly steady at area school districts (2 comments)
Editorial: Water, sewer rate hike a question of sooner or later (24 comments)

Reader Comments

Posted: Thursday, October 29, 2009
Article comment by: This is a great program

This program has tremendous benefits to families and students in Arizona. The state recognizes the education provided at these schools, whether secular or religious. For example, if a student attends a private religious school through 12th grade, the state acknoledges the education and the student is eligible for entrance into college. A person has free choice as to which organization he/she decides to donate, meaning the state is not mandating or directing support of anything religious. In the same way college students are allowed to deduct tuition expenses, Arizona offers this tax benefit for educational purposes.

Posted: Tuesday, October 27, 2009
Article comment by: It is still state money

No matter how the lawyer Keller tries to spin it, calling them scholarships, etc. it is still state money going to private and religious schools.

Article Comment Submission Form
Comments are not posted immediately. Submissions must adhere to our Use of Service Terms of Use agreement. The email and phone info you provide will not be visible to the public. Rambling or nonsensical comments may not be posted. Comments are limited to 1700 characters or less. In order for us to reasonably manage this feature we may limit your comment entries to five(5) per day.
Submit an Article Comment
First Name:
Last Name:
Anti-SPAM Passcode Click here to see a new mix of characters.
This is an anti-SPAM device. It is not case sensitive.

Advanced Search

HSE - Pulse Research
HSE - We want to hear from you
Find more about Weather in Cottonwood, AZ
Click for weather forecast

Submission Links
 •  Submit your feedback about our site

Find It Features Blogs Celebrate Submit Extras Other Publications Local Listings
Classifieds | Place Ad | Galleries | Kudos | Real Estate | Subscriber Services | e-News | RSS | Site Map | Find Verde Jobs | Contact Us
VV Fairgrounds

© Copyright 2014 Western News&Info, Inc.® The Verde Independent is the information source for Cottonwood and Verde Valley area communities in Northern Arizona. Original content may not be reprinted or distributed without the written permission of Western News&Info, Inc.® Verde News Online is a service of WNI. By using the Site, ®, you agree to abide and be bound by the Site's terms of use and Privacy Policy, which prohibit commercial use of any information on the Site. Click here to submit your questions, comments or suggestions. Verde News Online is a proud publication of Western News&Info Inc.® All Rights Reserved.

Software © 1998-2014 1up! Software, All Rights Reserved